Should we wreck our weather forecasts?

Musk and Trump are currently gutting the National Weather Service, which provides the data all US weather forecasters rely on. Without it, many more of us will die in tornadoes, hurricanes, and floods. Without good forecasts, farmers will have more trouble with planting and harvesting their crops. For a tiny investment, the National Weather Service provides a huge return to all of us.

Update 4/19/25: From the American Meteorological Society and the National Weather Association:

  • Stand Up for NOAA Research — The Time to Act is Now
  • The administration’s 2026 budget passback plan … would close all of NOAA’s weather, climate, and ocean Laboratories and Cooperative Institutes.
  • In effect, the scientific backbone and workforce needed to keep weather forecasts, alerts, and warnings accurate and effective will be drastically undercut, with unknown — yet almost certainly disastrous — consequences for public safety and economic health.
  • NOAA Research costs every American citizen less than a cup of coffee a year, with large returns on this small investment. This is a prime example of effective government — one that helps grow the economy and keeps people safe. Now is the time to reach out to your elected representatives. Consider installing the 5 Calls app on your phone to assist you. 

Earlier: From a report in Axios: “NOAA has reportedly been asked to prepare for shaving off up to one-third of its budget, which could disrupt core functions such as weather forecasting, climate data gathering and research.” and
“In the days leading up to the NOAA cuts, weather broadcasters and other meteorologists spoke out in favor of the agency on social media, noting its crucial role in providing accurate weather data and warnings.”

A powerful tornado near Waverly Road in the Lincoln, Nebraska, metro area on April 26, 2024. NOAA’s National Weather Service in Omaha, Nebraska, issued 48 tornado warnings that day—the most the office has ever issued in a single day. (Image credit: NOAA National Weather Service Office Omaha, Nebraska, and Katie Wargowsky)

From the NY Times (gift article): Cuts to National Weather Service Leave Forecasters Reeling

  • John Toohey-Morales, a longtime television meteorologist in Miami and former Weather Service forecaster, said that the firings raised serious public safety concerns. “I am telling you, the American people are going to suffer from all this,” he said. “Lives are being put in danger.”
  • As a broadcast meteorologist in a hurricane-prone area, Mr. Toohey-Morales said he relied continuously on the whole of the Weather Service to do his work. “I can’t do my job without the entire scaffolding that NOAA and National Weather Service provides,” he added.

From The Atlantic (gift article): The American Weather Forecast Is in Trouble:
Layoffs at NOAA will only make weather reports less reliable. They report: “It costs the public roughly $4 per year per person to keep the National Weather Service functioning. In return, the NWS provides its own raw weather data to anyone who wants the information, and publishes its own public-facing weather reports; virtually every private forecast relies on freely available NOAA data as the basis for its weather reports. Dan Satterfield, a veteran television meteorologist, told me on Bluesky that many times, he’d notice signs in the data that a storm could turn into a tornado, and that “NWS would have the warning out before I could get on air.”

These are changes that will make all of us poorer and less safe.

You can download the image below to make your own yard sign. See here for instructions.


Comments

One response to “Should we wreck our weather forecasts?”

  1. Cay Wilson Avatar
    Cay Wilson

    Absolutely not! The communities who depend on these warnings… the people who live in hurricane/tornato areas… the farmers, the fishermen… all these people will be forced to pay for life saving notification that should be free and open for all!!!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *